Hot Takes

Most Overrated Athletes Tier List

The names that get way more hype than the resume actually supports. Fight in the comments.

Ranked by 88 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Johnny Manziel

A: Tim Tebow, Carmelo Anthony

B: Tony Romo

C: Dwight Howard, Colin Kaepernick

D: Cristiano Ronaldo

F: Tim Lincecum

Discussion

WeirdDumpling: Joe Namath is in the Hall for one game and threw 50 more picks than touchdowns. Where is he?

TinyRaccoon: Tebow. Great college player, the hype as an NFL QB was never about his actual passing.

penguinlurker: Where's Lonzo Ball?

nated36: Lincecum won two Cy Youngs back to back. How is he on this list

SaltyPotato: Ronaldo overrated is a wild take

More Hot Takes tier lists

• Most Underrated Fast Food Chains Tier List
• Worst Video Game Launches Tier List
• Best Decades to Grow Up In Tier List
• Is It Soup? Tier List
• Comment Sections by How Civil They Are Tier List
• Superheroes as Roommates Tier List
• Gen Z Slang Tier List
• Superpowers Tier List