Daily + New

Hot Takes

Most Overrated Athletes Tier List

Tebow had one magic playoff run in Denver and got treated like a franchise QB for years. this list is hype vs resume

Ranked by 72 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Tim Tebow, Johnny Manziel

A: Carmelo Anthony

B: Tony Romo, Dwight Howard

C: Colin Kaepernick

D: Cristiano Ronaldo

F: Tim Lincecum

Discussion

possumhater2474: Tebow. Great college player, the hype as an NFL QB was never about his actual passing.
throwaway85945: Where's Lonzo Ball?
alexs2587: Joe Namath is in the Hall for one game and threw 50 more picks than touchdowns. Where is he?
throwaway24923: Ronaldo overrated is a wild take
wizardranker: Lincecum won two Cy Youngs back to back. How is he on this list

More Hot Takes tier lists