Hot Takes

Divisive Halloween Candy Tier List

Ranking the Halloween candies that spark the most trick-or-treat bag arguments.

Ranked by 14 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Full Size Chocolate Bars

A: Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

B: Smarties, Candy Corn, Black Licorice

C: Tootsie Rolls, Candy Cigarettes, Necco Wafers

D: Mary Janes

F: Circus Peanuts

Discussion

anam1: the full size bar house was legendary

golden_frog: Raisins

soggy_raccoon_88: Candy cigarettes always tasted like Pepto to me

LazyPanda8168: Candy corn in C is the most Reddit thing ever. People love it or hate it, no in between.

throwaway19919: Circus peanuts are undeniably the worst candy available in the US. Fake banana flavor shaped like a peanut, texture of a dry sponge.

More Hot Takes tier lists

• Most Underrated Fast Food Chains Tier List
• Worst Video Game Launches Tier List
• Best Decades to Grow Up In Tier List
• Is It Soup? Tier List
• Comment Sections by How Civil They Are Tier List
• Superheroes as Roommates Tier List
• Gen Z Slang Tier List
• Superpowers Tier List