Who wins?
Shovel vs Crowbar
Shovel wins 87% to 13%. 53 more put them in the same row. From Zombie Apocalypse Weapons Tier List. Pick a side.
dark_dumpling on Shovel: digs graves, chops heads, fixes gardens after
random_possum_75 on Crowbar: Gordon Freeman used it for a whole game against headcrabs
Zombie Apocalypse Weapons Tier List: the full ranking