Who wins?
Pirate vs Art the Clown
Art the Clown wins 52% to 48%. 124 more put them in the same row. From Halloween Costumes Tier List. Pick a side.
QuietWalrus9914 on Pirate: eye patch, bandana, done in five minutes
tired_possum_4759 on Art the Clown: if you follow horror subs you'd think one in ten people is Art
Halloween Costumes Tier List: the full ranking