Who wins?
Tom Brady vs Peyton Manning
Tom Brady wins 74% to 26%. 13 more put them in the same row. From NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Tier List. Pick a side.
LostNugget on Tom Brady: played until 45 and won a title in Tampa at 43
pigeonenjoyer7656 on Peyton Manning: five MVPs and the 2013 season with 55 touchdowns
NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Tier List: the full ranking