Who wins?
Peyton Manning vs Joe Montana
Joe Montana wins 83% to 17%. 13 more put them in the same row. From NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Tier List. Pick a side.
pigeonenjoyer7656 on Peyton Manning: five MVPs and the 2013 season with 55 touchdowns
biscuitranker on Joe Montana: 4 for 4 in Super Bowls with zero picks thrown
NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Tier List: the full ranking