Who wins?
A Silent Voice vs Clannad: After Story
Clannad: After Story wins 81% to 19%. 5 more put them in the same row. From Romance Anime Tier List. Pick a side.
weird_goose on A Silent Voice: the bridge scene and Shoko's arc
WeirdBiscuit5018 on Clannad: After Story: Tomoya's arc with his dad and Ushio destroyed me
Romance Anime Tier List: the full ranking