Who wins?
Clannad: After Story vs Toradora!
Toradora! wins 78% to 22%. 9 more put them in the same row. From Romance Anime Tier List. Pick a side.
WeirdBiscuit5018 on Clannad: After Story: Tomoya's arc with his dad and Ushio destroyed me
silent_badger on Toradora!: the December rewatch every year
Romance Anime Tier List: the full ranking