Who wins?
Lucille vs Katana
Lucille wins 59% to 41%. 36 more put them in the same row. From Zombie Apocalypse Weapons Tier List. Pick a side.
xXOtterXx on Lucille: a bat with barbed wire, cool but it'll get stuck
LazyDumpling6 on Katana: a real katana in trained hands is the best melee weapon on the list
Zombie Apocalypse Weapons Tier List: the full ranking