Who wins?
Johnny Manziel vs Carmelo Anthony
Johnny Manziel wins 86% to 14%. 106 more put them in the same row. From Most Overrated Athletes Tier List. Pick a side.
feral_toaster_42 on Johnny Manziel: one Heisman and two seasons of chaos in Cleveland, the hype was never matched
emilym85 on Carmelo Anthony: a scoring machine in a superteam era who never won
Most Overrated Athletes Tier List: the full ranking