Who wins?
Colin Kaepernick vs Tim Lincecum
Colin Kaepernick wins 92% to 8%. 67 more put them in the same row. From Most Overrated Athletes Tier List. Pick a side.
frogranker on Colin Kaepernick: a great 2012 run and then everyone acted like he was a legend
mattp73 on Tim Lincecum: fell off a cliff after 2011 when the velocity dropped, but the peak was real
Most Overrated Athletes Tier List: the full ranking