Who wins?
Coldplay (2016) vs Usher (2024)
Usher (2024) wins 72% to 28%. 16 more put them in the same row. From Super Bowl Halftime Shows Tier List. Pick a side.
pigeonstan29 on Coldplay (2016): got completely outshined by their own guest stars
jess_t15 on Usher (2024): roller skates and Alicia Keys, fun show
Super Bowl Halftime Shows Tier List: the full ranking