Who wins?
Coldplay (2016) vs Janet Jackson (2004)
Janet Jackson (2004) wins 54% to 46%. 18 more put them in the same row. From Super Bowl Halftime Shows Tier List. Pick a side.
pigeonstan29 on Coldplay (2016): got completely outshined by their own guest stars
throwaway83773 on Janet Jackson (2004): basically helped invent YouTube
Super Bowl Halftime Shows Tier List: the full ranking