Who wins?
St. Anger vs Reload
Reload wins 89% to 11%. 17 more put them in the same row. From Metallica Albums Tier List. Pick a side.
mangodad on St. Anger: the raw anger is real and Frantic kind of rips
SpicyBadger5 on Reload: Fuel is great, the rest is leftovers from Load
Metallica Albums Tier List: the full ranking