Daily + New

Music

Metallica Albums Tier List

Master of Puppets on top, St. Anger at the bottom. that snare still haunts me

Ranked by 137 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Master of Puppets, Ride the Lightning

A: Metallica (The Black Album), ...And Justice for All, Kill 'Em All

B: 72 Seasons, Hardwired

C: Load, Reload

D: St. Anger

Discussion

retired_badger_28: First four are flawless, Black Album is great, then it gets complicated
FrozenMoose: Load in C is criminal. The Outlaw Torn and Bleeding Me are top tier Metallica.
jake_o58: No Death Magnetic?
BenTheGreat: St. Anger in F. The snare drum alone.
throwaway9383: Justice would be S if you could hear the bass

More Music tier lists