Who wins?
...And Justice for All vs Metallica (The Black Album)
Metallica (The Black Album) wins 58% to 42%. 43 more put them in the same row. From Metallica Albums Tier List. Pick a side.
bored_dumpling_8 on ...And Justice for All: best songwriting they ever did, if only you could hear the bass
RandomWaffle16 on Metallica (The Black Album): Bob Rock made them sound massive, Sad But True is heavy as anything
Metallica Albums Tier List: the full ranking