Who wins?

Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs Retiring "for good" video (2023)

Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) wins 90% to 10%. 84 more put them in the same row. From Tom Brady's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

hamstergamer7951 on Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008): it's a huge moment in his career even if it's a loss. the list is moments not wins

JakeRates on Retiring "for good" video (2023): short and sweet at least, one take on the beach

Tom Brady's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019)
• Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs The Roast of Tom Brady (2024)
• Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009)
• Retiring "for good" video (2023) vs The Roast of Tom Brady (2024)