Who wins?
Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009)
Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) wins 88% to 12%. 56 more put them in the same row. From Tom Brady's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.
hamstergamer7951 on Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008): it's a huge moment in his career even if it's a loss. the list is moments not wins
dan_d31 on Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009): five touchdown passes in a single quarter is insane
Tom Brady's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking
More matchups
- Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019)
- Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs The Roast of Tom Brady (2024)
- Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008) vs Retiring "for good" video (2023)
- Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) vs 50 TD season with Randy Moss (2007)
- Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) vs Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019)
- Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) vs Juking Urlacher in the snow (2010)