Who wins?
Ulysses S. Grant vs Jimmy Carter
Dead even: 48 picks for Ulysses S. Grant, 48 for Jimmy Carter. 32 more put them in the same row. From US Presidents I Could Beat in a Fight Tier List. Pick a side.
WetBurrito on Ulysses S. Grant: he's a quiet guy who hated bloodshed, he'd just walk away
throwaway3222 on Jimmy Carter: he's the nicest man alive, he would not throw a punch
US Presidents I Could Beat in a Fight Tier List: the full ranking