Who wins?
Cherry vs Pumpkin
Cherry wins 70% to 30%. 8 more put them in the same row. From Pie Flavors Tier List. Pick a side.
wet_toaster on Cherry: the lattice top was made for this pie
throwaway57484 on Pumpkin: Thanksgiving doesn't happen without it and Costco sells a giant one for six bucks
Pie Flavors Tier List: the full ranking