Food & Drink

Pie Flavors Tier List

Thanksgiving dessert table, settled once and for all.

Ranked by 298 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Pecan, Key lime

A: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Pumpkin

B: Sweet potato, Lemon meringue, Chocolate cream

C: Banana cream, Rhubarb, Chess

D: Mince

F: Raisin

Discussion

omar.t2930: Costco pumpkin pie is so good and so cheap I stopped making my own years ago. A tier is fair.

penguinkid59: chess pie in C is a hate crime against the south

pandakid: Rhubarb in C? Strawberry rhubarb is top three and I'm tired of pretending it isn't.

MegaWaffle23: Publix key lime or nothing

CursedMango: Apple in S is correct but only with a slice of sharp cheddar on top. My grandma used to say apple pie without cheese is like a kiss without a squeeze.

More Food & Drink tier lists

• Fruits by How Annoying They Are to Eat Tier List
• Boba/Bubble Tea Chains Tier List
• Pasta Shapes Tier List
• Energy Drinks Tier List
• Pizza Chains Tier List
• Coffee Drinks Tier List
• World Cuisines Tier List
• Cookie Brands & Types Tier List