Who wins?
Dan Marino vs Aaron Rodgers
Dan Marino wins 57% to 43%. 8 more put them in the same row. From NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Tier List. Pick a side.
feral_burrito_7542 on Dan Marino: 5084 yards in 1984 when nobody threw like that
GoldenPigeon on Aaron Rodgers: the most talented thrower ever, those 2011 and 2014 seasons were absurd
NFL Quarterbacks of All Time Tier List: the full ranking