Anime

Supernatural Horror Anime Tier List

Ranking anime with horror, supernatural, and paranormal themes.

Ranked by 22 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Higurashi: When They Cry, Shiki

A: Hellsing Ultimate

B: Jigoku Shoujo, Ghost Hunt

C: Tokyo Ghoul, The Promised Neverland, Another

D: Corpse Party

Discussion

pandastan: Shiki has at least two scenes that wrecked me. The one with the video camera was brutal.

WeirdPossum70: Promised Neverland season 1 is an S. Season 2 drags the whole thing to C.

throwaway48339: Another is mostly funny deaths and an umbrella scene

ryan_d7569: Higurashi in S. The original, not the new one that fell apart in the second half.

More Anime tier lists

• Best Anime of 2025 Tier List
• Strongest Anime Characters Tier List
• Dandadan Characters Tier List
• Anime Rivalries Tier List
• Gateway Anime for Beginners Tier List
• Overrated Anime Tier List
• Dragon Ball Characters Tier List
• Sports Anime Tier List