Who wins?
Marry You vs All of Me (John Legend song)
Marry You wins 57% to 43%. 17 more put them in the same row. From Wedding Songs Tier List. Pick a side.
sleepy_toaster on Marry You: a flash mob song, not a first dance song
crispy_otter on All of Me (John Legend song): the piano and his voice, still a lovely first dance
Wedding Songs Tier List: the full ranking