Who wins?
A Star Is Born (Soundtrack) vs The Fame
Dead even: 5 picks for A Star Is Born (Soundtrack), 5 for The Fame. 9 more put them in the same row. From Lady Gaga Albums Tier List. Pick a side.
SuperPenguin on A Star Is Born (Soundtrack): Shallow won the Oscar and Gaga's acting was great
HumblePickle on The Fame: Just Dance and Poker Face started it all
Lady Gaga Albums Tier List: the full ranking