Who wins?

The Thing vs Trick 'r Treat

The Thing wins 87% to 13%. 30 more put them in the same row. From Halloween Movies Tier List. Pick a side.

angry_biscuit_61 on The Thing: the blood test scene, enough said

CursedBiscuit9379 on Trick 'r Treat: the most Halloween movie ever made, it's all rules and traditions

Halloween Movies Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• The Thing vs The Nightmare Before Christmas
• The Thing vs It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
• The Thing vs Halloween
• Trick 'r Treat vs It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
• Trick 'r Treat vs Hocus Pocus
• Trick 'r Treat vs Coraline