Who wins?
Sleepy Hollow vs The Shining
The Shining wins 55% to 45%. 21 more put them in the same row. From Halloween Movies Tier List. Pick a side.
RandomPenguin5606 on Sleepy Hollow: not a great movie but the atmosphere is unbeatable, it looks like October
weird_nugget_26 on The Shining: Kubrick made a hotel scarier than any monster
Halloween Movies Tier List: the full ranking