Who wins?
Matt Smith vs David Tennant
David Tennant wins 83% to 17%. 7 more put them in the same row. From Doctor Who Actors Tier List. Pick a side.
throwaway15085 on Matt Smith: bow ties are cool, and the Eleventh Hour is the perfect introduction
SilentWaffle12 on David Tennant: Blink and the Waters of Mars are the best episodes of the revival
Doctor Who Actors Tier List: the full ranking