Who wins?
Jeanette Peterson vs Lily Aldrin
Lily Aldrin wins 84% to 16%. 28 more put them in the same row. From How I Met Your Mother Characters Tier List. Pick a side.
zach_d24 on Jeanette Peterson: a stalker cop with zero chill, why did he keep dating her
ItsBurritoXx on Lily Aldrin: Alyson Hannigan makes even the worst Lily plots funny
How I Met Your Mother Characters Tier List: the full ranking