Who wins?
Carrie Underwood vs Garth Brooks
Garth Brooks wins 70% to 30%. 47 more put them in the same row. From Country Artists Tier List. Pick a side.
tacomain on Carrie Underwood: best pure vocalist on this list
nate.s4927 on Garth Brooks: best selling solo artist in US history, he's top tier
Country Artists Tier List: the full ranking