Who wins?
Butter Pecan vs Vanilla
Vanilla wins 59% to 41%. 28 more put them in the same row. From Ice Cream Flavors Tier List. Pick a side.
LostBadger on Butter Pecan: grandpa ice cream and grandpa was right
FeralRaccoon on Vanilla: the real test of a shop, if the vanilla's good, everything is
Ice Cream Flavors Tier List: the full ranking