Who wins?
Werewolf vs Mothman
Werewolf wins 59% to 41%. 29 more put them in the same row. From Mythical Creatures Tier List. Pick a side.
tony.z7045 on Werewolf: full moon horror at its best
throwaway95892 on Mothman: a red eyed moth guy from West Virginia got a whole festival
Mythical Creatures Tier List: the full ranking