Who wins?
Horimiya vs Clannad
Horimiya wins 71% to 29%. 53 more put them in the same row. From Slice of Life Anime Tier List. Pick a side.
golden_nugget_51 on Horimiya: the most realistic high school romance in anime
MegaNoodle1099 on Clannad: After Story is the saddest anime ever made
Slice of Life Anime Tier List: the full ranking