Who wins?
Romance Dawn vs Fish-Man Island
Fish-Man Island wins 56% to 44%. 45 more put them in the same row. From One Piece Arcs Tier List. Pick a side.
dumplinghater7697 on Romance Dawn: if this wasn't good the manga wouldn't have happened
mega_goblin_7 on Fish-Man Island: themes about inherited hatred are actually deep, people miss that
One Piece Arcs Tier List: the full ranking