Who wins?

Jiraiya's death (Shippuden 133) vs Final Valley fight (Shippuden 476)

Final Valley fight (Shippuden 476) wins 52% to 48%. 28 more put them in the same row. From Naruto's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

silent_walrus_52 on Jiraiya's death (Shippuden 133): him writing the code on the toad's back while sinking. brutal

chunky_goose_2316 on Final Valley fight (Shippuden 476): they ended the rivalry the right way, both of them lying there laughing

Naruto's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• Jiraiya's death (Shippuden 133) vs Rock Lee drops his weights (Ep 48)
• Jiraiya's death (Shippuden 133) vs Naruto meets Kushina (Shippuden 246)
• Jiraiya's death (Shippuden 133) vs Valley of the End (Ep 134)
• Final Valley fight (Shippuden 476) vs Naruto meets Kushina (Shippuden 246)
• Final Valley fight (Shippuden 476) vs The village cheers Naruto after Pain (Shippuden 175)
• Final Valley fight (Shippuden 476) vs Haku and Zabuza's deaths (Ep 19)