Who wins?

All Might vs Nomu, Plus Ultra (S1E12) vs Deku vs Muscular (S3E5)

All Might vs Nomu, Plus Ultra (S1E12) wins 52% to 48%. 140 more put them in the same row. From My Hero Academia's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

sandwichmain46 on All Might vs Nomu, Plus Ultra (S1E12): The speech while he's bleeding out of his side is so good

SleepyGoose on Deku vs Muscular (S3E5): One Million Percent Delaware Detroit Smash. I still put this on to hype myself up.

My Hero Academia's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• All Might vs Nomu, Plus Ultra (S1E12) vs Deku's 100% vs Overhaul with Eri (S4E13)
• All Might vs Nomu, Plus Ultra (S1E12) vs Deku's final Smash on Shigaraki (S8E8)
• All Might vs Nomu, Plus Ultra (S1E12) vs Deku vs Todoroki, It's your power (S2E10)
• Deku vs Muscular (S3E5) vs Deku's final Smash on Shigaraki (S8E8)
• Deku vs Muscular (S3E5) vs Endeavor vs High-End (S4E25)
• Deku vs Muscular (S3E5) vs Armored All Might vs All For One (S7)