Who wins?
Pumpkin Pie vs Mashed Potatoes
Mashed Potatoes wins 78% to 22%. 17 more put them in the same row. From Thanksgiving Dishes Tier List. Pick a side.
raccoonstan2 on Pumpkin Pie: Costco pumpkin pie is a Thanksgiving tradition by itself
MariaEats on Mashed Potatoes: the side I'm in charge of every year, butter is the whole secret
Thanksgiving Dishes Tier List: the full ranking