Who wins?
Simple Plan vs Good Charlotte
Good Charlotte wins 76% to 24%. 18 more put them in the same row. From 2000s Pop Punk Bands Tier List. Pick a side.
throwaway7846 on Simple Plan: I'm Just a Kid became a meme and that's okay
NotPigeon2k on Good Charlotte: they were huge in 2003
2000s Pop Punk Bands Tier List: the full ranking