Who wins?

"I shook up the world" vs Liston (1964) vs Thrilla in Manila vs Frazier (1975)

Thrilla in Manila vs Frazier (1975) wins 57% to 43%. 40 more put them in the same row. From Muhammad Ali's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

GrumpyCactus3819 on "I shook up the world" vs Liston (1964): huge underdog against the scariest man alive, and he called it

throwaway96524 on Thrilla in Manila vs Frazier (1975): the most brutal heavyweight fight ever, Frazier's corner stopped it before the 15th

Muhammad Ali's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• "I shook up the world" vs Liston (1964) vs Standing over Liston, the phantom punch (1965)
• "I shook up the world" vs Liston (1964) vs Refusing the draft (1967)
• "I shook up the world" vs Liston (1964) vs Dismantling Cleveland Williams (1966)
• Thrilla in Manila vs Frazier (1975) vs Lighting the Olympic cauldron in Atlanta (1996)
• Thrilla in Manila vs Frazier (1975) vs Standing over Liston, the phantom punch (1965)
• Thrilla in Manila vs Frazier (1975) vs Rumble in the Jungle vs Foreman (1974)