Who wins?

The Lightning Thief vs The Battle of the Labyrinth

The Battle of the Labyrinth wins 64% to 36%. 11 more put them in the same row. From Percy Jackson Books Tier List. Pick a side.

DarkTaco3262 on The Lightning Thief: it's the one that got me reading, finished it in a day

silent_noodle_1990 on The Battle of the Labyrinth: the most underrated book in the series

Percy Jackson Books Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• The Lightning Thief vs Heroes of Olympus
• The Lightning Thief vs The Titan's Curse
• The Lightning Thief vs Trials of Apollo
• The Battle of the Labyrinth vs The Titan's Curse
• The Battle of the Labyrinth vs The Last Olympian
• The Battle of the Labyrinth vs Heroes of Olympus