Who wins?
Witch vs Mario and Luigi
Dead even: 159 picks for Witch, 157 for Mario and Luigi. 158 more put them in the same row. From Halloween Costumes Tier List. Pick a side.
josh_l9940 on Witch: you can go cute or full Hocus Pocus, nobody judges
TinyHamster2509 on Mario and Luigi: the best couples or best friends costume, instantly recognized
Halloween Costumes Tier List: the full ranking