Who wins?

Wimbledon 2009 final, 16-14 in the fifth vs Roddick (2009) vs AO 2017 final comeback vs Nadal (2017)

AO 2017 final comeback vs Nadal (2017) wins 55% to 45%. 134 more put them in the same row. From Roger Federer's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

possumhater97 on Wimbledon 2009 final, 16-14 in the fifth vs Roddick (2009): slam number 15 to pass Sampras with Sampras sitting in the box

ChunkyOtter315 on AO 2017 final comeback vs Nadal (2017): down a break in the fifth after six months out injured. nobody expected another slam

Roger Federer's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• Wimbledon 2009 final, 16-14 in the fifth vs Roddick (2009) vs Ending Djokovic's streak at Roland Garros (2011)
• Wimbledon 2009 final, 16-14 in the fifth vs Roddick (2009) vs Finally winning Roland Garros (2009)
• Wimbledon 2009 final, 16-14 in the fifth vs Roddick (2009) vs Beating Sampras at Wimbledon as a teenager (2001)
• AO 2017 final comeback vs Nadal (2017) vs Finally winning Roland Garros (2009)
• AO 2017 final comeback vs Nadal (2017) vs Ending Djokovic's streak at Roland Garros (2011)