Who wins?

2008 Wimbledon final vs Nadal (2008) vs Tweener winner vs Djokovic at the US Open (2009)

Tweener winner vs Djokovic at the US Open (2009) wins 57% to 43%. 78 more put them in the same row. From Roger Federer's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

frozen_burrito_8260 on 2008 Wimbledon final vs Nadal (2008): he lost but it is still the greatest match ever played. the passing shots in the fourth set tiebreak

frozen_burrito_8260 on Tweener winner vs Djokovic at the US Open (2009): between the legs for a winner to set up match point. the most famous shot ever

Roger Federer's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• 2008 Wimbledon final vs Nadal (2008) vs Laver Cup farewell holding hands with Nadal (2022)
• 2008 Wimbledon final vs Nadal (2008) vs Eighth Wimbledon without dropping a set (2017)
• 2008 Wimbledon final vs Nadal (2008) vs "God, it's killing me" speech at AO 2009 (2009)
• Tweener winner vs Djokovic at the US Open (2009) vs Beating Sampras at Wimbledon as a teenager (2001)
• Tweener winner vs Djokovic at the US Open (2009) vs Laver Cup farewell holding hands with Nadal (2022)
• Tweener winner vs Djokovic at the US Open (2009) vs Ending Djokovic's streak at Roland Garros (2011)