Who wins?
Riverdale vs Supernatural
Dead even: 12 picks for Riverdale, 12 for Supernatural. 112 more put them in the same row. From Shows That Went On Too Long Tier List. Pick a side.
MrPickle2k on Riverdale: started as a murder mystery and ended with time travel and a maple syrup cult
RyanTheGreat on Supernatural: the perfect ending was season 5. Then ten more seasons
Shows That Went On Too Long Tier List: the full ranking