Who wins?
Cleveland Guardians vs New York Yankees
Cleveland Guardians wins 71% to 29%. 15 more put them in the same row. From MLB 2026 Postseason Teams Tier List. Pick a side.
SuperNoodle13 on Cleveland Guardians: won the division by a game but the week off clearly hurt them
RandomBurrito41 on New York Yankees: great rotation, they can win three straight
MLB 2026 Postseason Teams Tier List: the full ranking