Movies & TV
Live-Action Disney Remakes Tier List
the 2016 jungle book was actually good. the photoreal lion king had zero facial expressions
Ranked by 73 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.
The crowd's ranking
S: The Jungle Book
A: Cinderella
B: Lilo & Stitch, Maleficent, Aladdin
C: Beauty and the Beast, The Little Mermaid
D: Moana, Dumbo, Mulan
F: The Lion King, Snow White, Pinocchio
Discussion
BenPlays: Mulan 2020 took away the whole point. Original Mulan wins by being smart, new one just has magic chi.
possumkid52: Moana is a near shot for shot remake that somehow lost all the energy. I nodded off during the Shiny scene. D is generous
throwaway24361: Beauty and the Beast in C is fair. Luke Evans as Gaston was perfect, Emma Watson was not.
retired_raccoon: Pinocchio and Snow White tied for last, I won't elaborate
AnaRates: Lion King 2019 defines soulless. Great visuals, zero emotion, everyone sounds like they recorded with a gun to their head.
ThePigeon69: Jungle Book worked because it took the best bits of the 67 film and actually gave Mowgli an arc