Movies & TV

Oscar Best Pictures That Aged Badly Tier List

Rank Best Picture winners that make you go 'that won over what?' today.

Ranked by 17 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

B: Dances with Wolves

C: How Green Was My Valley, Shakespeare in Love

D: Driving Miss Daisy, Gigi, Green Book, The Greatest Show on Earth, Around the World in Eighty Days, Crash

F: Cimarron

Discussion

sam_t37: Gigi opens with an old man singing Thank Heaven for Little Girls and it gets worse from there

otternerd7885: No American Beauty? It aged like milk for obvious reasons.

SaltyMango25: How Green Was My Valley beat Citizen Kane. Never forget.

matt.a5553: Crash is the easy answer and it's the right one. It beat Brokeback Mountain.

NotBurrito: Dances with Wolves in B, it's fine, it just beat Goodfellas

More Movies & TV tier lists

• Best TV Shows of 2025 Tier List
• House of the Dragon Characters Tier List
• Taylor Sheridan Shows Tier List
• The White Lotus Seasons Tier List
• The Boys Characters Tier List
• Stranger Things Characters Tier List
• Late Night Talk Show Hosts Tier List
• Joker Actors Tier List