Who wins?
Dark Shadows vs Mars Attacks!
Mars Attacks! wins 84% to 16%. 24 more put them in the same row. From Tim Burton Movies Tier List. Pick a side.
luis_z26 on Dark Shadows: surprisingly good, felt like a pilot for a great show
throwaway20685 on Mars Attacks!: ack ack ack, a perfect cheesy B movie
Tim Burton Movies Tier List: the full ranking