Who wins?
Erza Scarlet vs Lucy Heartfilia
Lucy Heartfilia wins 55% to 45%. 233 more put them in the same row. From Fairy Tail Characters Tier List. Pick a side.
raccoonkid5238 on Erza Scarlet: beating 100 monsters solo in Pandemonium is the most Fairy Tail moment ever
kim.k32 on Lucy Heartfilia: the actual heart of the guild, half the story is told through her eyes
Fairy Tail Characters Tier List: the full ranking