Who wins?

Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019) vs Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009)

Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) wins 68% to 32%. 69 more put them in the same row. From Tom Brady's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

PriyaTheGreat on Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019): defense won it, but it still counts as six and passed the Steelers

dan_d31 on Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009): five touchdown passes in a single quarter is insane

Tom Brady's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019) vs Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008)
• Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019) vs 50 TD season with Randy Moss (2007)
• Super Bowl LIII win over the Rams (2019) vs The Roast of Tom Brady (2024)
• Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) vs 50 TD season with Randy Moss (2007)
• Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) vs Juking Urlacher in the snow (2010)
• Five TDs in one quarter vs the Titans in the snow (2009) vs Helmet Catch loss, Super Bowl XLII (2008)